Posted by Sunil Saini on Friday, November 1, 2019 12:53pm
For quite some time, I had been thinking about writing a blog about mortgage pre-payment penalty and the way it is calculated. Recent article about a consumer going public about his $17,000 penalty imposed by TD Bank and some bank employees going public about sales pressure making the clients interest secondary to them, encouraged me further to do it sooner than later.
Prepayment Penalty: Why banks want to charge you a pre-payment penalty? Whenever a borrower takes a loan/mortgage from a lender, it is closed for a specific term that can vary anywhere from 1 year to 10 years. In the event, the borrower ends up selling his/her home earlier and decides not to port the mortgage to the next property, the lender will end up charging a penalty to that borrower that is normally higher of -
3 months interest or Interest rate differential, normally called IRD Whereas 3 months interest is very easy to understand, the formula for calculating IRD is very complicated and no lender in my opinion gives a very clear picture about this calculation and this leads to huge surprises to borrowers at a later date.
Lenders normally use terms like posted rate, discounted rate, etc in such calculations. In my opinion a very clear and concise calculation of this way of calculating pre-payment penalty should be given to each borrower at the time of documentation signing and further the regulatory bodies should impose strict guidelines about such calculations and under any circumstances the lenders should not be allowed to use – (posted rate at the time of discharge – discounted rate at time of borrowing) to calculate IRD and there has to be some sort of max amount that should be imposed on lenders that they can charge.
I have seen a case recently wherein a client of mine from big 5 ported his mortgage to next property and still lost $1700 in the process despite the fact that his new mortgage was only about $7000 less than his previous mortgage. In another case, my client was charged mortgage penalty along with re-investment fee.
No wonder banks make a few billions as their quarterly profit. I hope and demand the government and our regulatory bodies to hold all lenders accountable to higher moral and ethical grounds. Not all home sellers make profit on their sales and not all sellers sell out of good reasons. I have seen clients selling homes due to sour marriages, death in family, loss of job, etc. Hope this blog reaches our politicians and regulatory bodies who are mandated to protect consumers in financial industry.
BTW I am an MBA from Schulich School of Business with over 15 years of experience in the real estate industry. If you need to get any advice or simply need to know your options, please feel free to call me at my cell.